About the Author

Elise Hittinger - Courage Coach

Elise is a Courage Coach, Certified Hypnotherapist, and NLP Practitioner dedicated to helping anxious equestrians get out of their heads and back in the saddle with calm and confidence. Through her "Turn Riding Fear Around Podcast" and bestselling book, 'Rise from Fear to Courage,' she empowers riders to quiet the noise, reset their nervous systems, and reconnect with the joy of riding. She leads a thriving community of over 1,600 riders in her 'Overcoming Anxiety & Fear Horseback Riding' Facebook group. Learn more about Elise's transformative coaching through a Calm-Ride Strategy call.

How to Rebuild Riding Confidence After Losing It

Those moments when you wonder if it might just be time to quit.
The tears that come when it feels like anxiety has won.
The climb back can seem impossible.
But there is your horse, waiting patiently for your confidence to show up.
Except...
Maybe confidence isn't something we wait for.
Maybe we rebuild it.

Step 1: Know That Riding Can Feel Good Again

The first step is believing it is possible to enjoy riding again.
There are many riders who have gone before you and found their way back to enjoying their horses.
I'm one of them.
There are bumps in the road.
There are obstacles that challenge us as riders.
There are days when taking the next step feels ridiculously hard.
But taking those steps anyway?
That becomes the reward.
One step.
And then another.
That's how confidence is built.

Step 2: Go to the Edge of Your Comfort Zone

The second step is to go to the edge of your comfort zone...
and take one more step.
Not ten.
Not “just push through.”
One.
Then do it again.
And again.
Confidence often comes when you've repeated something enough times that your body starts to believe it is safe.
I love that idea.
By going to the edge of your comfort zone and taking just one more step, you're repeating what you've already done while adding just enough to keep moving forward.
For me, my first ride back was four steps.
That was it.
Four.
A trail ride felt like climbing Mt. Everest.
Taking four steps felt like standing at the bottom of the mountain with a map in my hand.
 Rider taking small steps to rebuild confidence after losing confidence horseback riding

But those four steps were just barely outside my comfort zone.
So I did them.
Then it was 50 steps.
Then it was 1/4 of the way around the pasture.
Little by little, those first steps became boring.
And the next steps became possible.

Step 3: Stop Measuring Yourself Against the Rider You Used to Be

This one can be hard.
We remember the rider who galloped.
Jumped.
Trail rode for hours.
Got on without thinking twice.
Then we look at today's four steps and decide they don't count.
They count.
Your confidence does not care what you could do ten years ago.
It rebuilds from what you do today.
Four steps is a victory.
Standing at the mounting block is a victory.
Putting your foot in the stirrup and deciding, “Not today,” for a good reason is a victory.
The goal is not to prove you're still the rider you used to be.
The goal is to start enjoying being the rider you are now.
 Rider enjoying horseback riding again after rebuilding riding confidence


Maybe Your Confidence Wasn't Gone

This is the part I wish I had understood sooner.
Maybe we do not actually lose our riding confidence.
Maybe it gets buried.
Buried under an accident.
A scary ride.
A horse that changed.
A body that changed.
Years away from riding.
A whole lot of “What if?”

And every small, successful experience starts uncovering it again.

One ride.
One small win.
One step at a time.
So if you're sitting there wondering...

Will I ever get my riding confidence back?

Maybe there's a better question.

What's one step I can take today to start rebuilding it?

Because your horse is not waiting for the rider you used to be.
Your horse is waiting for you.
And four steps absolutely count.

Ready for Your Next Step?

If you're tired of trying to figure out how to rebuild your riding confidence on your own, let's figure out your next step together.
A Calm Ride Strategy is a free place to talk about what's keeping you stuck, where you'd like to be, and what your next calm, doable step could look like.
No Mt. Everest required.
Just the next step.


0 Comments

Leave a Comment


Hey there! I’m Elise Hittinger—Fear Slayer, Confidence Creator, and your go-to Courage Coach.

 
Once upon a time, I was that fearless kid riding deep into Angeles National Forest without a second thought. Then bam—life threw me a plot twist. A horse flipped on me, pinning me beneath it, and fear crept in like an uninvited guest who wouldn’t leave.

That moment tested everything. But here’s the wild part—I walked away with only bruises and a divine reminder that I wasn’t done yet. Fear may have stolen my joy for a while, but it did not get the final say.

Fast forward to a move to Kentucky, where the trails were calling my name. I had two choices: let fear keep the reins or take them back. Spoiler alert—I took them back. Now, I help other riders (and, honestly, anyone sick of fear running their life) do the same.

I make fear pack its little bags and GTFO. Whether it’s through hypnotherapy, NLP, or a little well-placed humor, I help people trade anxiety for confidence, doubt for courage, and overthinking for action.

So, if you’re ready to kick fear to the curb and rediscover the joy you deserve—I’m here for it. Let’s do this.

Contact