About the Author

Elise Hittinger - Courage Coach

Elise is a Courage Coach, Certified Hypnotherapist, and NLP Practitioner dedicated to helping anxious equestrians get out of their heads and back in the saddle with calm and confidence. Through her "Turn Riding Fear Around Podcast" and bestselling book, 'Rise from Fear to Courage,' she empowers riders to quiet the noise, reset their nervous systems, and reconnect with the joy of riding. She leads a thriving community of over 1,600 riders in her 'Overcoming Anxiety & Fear Horseback Riding' Facebook group. Learn more about Elise's transformative coaching through a Calm-Ride Strategy call.

How Your Thoughts Affect Your Horseback Riding Confidence

How Your Thoughts Affect Your Horseback Riding Confidence

Your horse hasn't done a SINGLE thing wrong today.

But your brain has already imagined 15 different ways this ride could go sideways!

You're standing by the mounting block, reins in hand, while your horse looks more concerned about a stray piece of hay than the ride ahead. Meanwhile, your brain is producing a disaster movie.

Sound familiar? Let's get curious about what's happening.

Your Thoughts Have a Body Language

Picture a spook before it happens, and you might grip with your legs, hold your breath, or tip your weight forward. You didn't choose to ride that way. Your body responded to the thought.

Your horse may feel those changes and wonder what you've noticed. Now you're both paying attention to a danger that might not be there.

Your horse feels what your body is saying. That's one reason thoughts can affect your horseback riding confidence before you even leave the mounting block.

 Elise Hittinger riding Binky calmly, demonstrating relaxed horseback riding and confidence in the saddle.

One “What If?” Can Change the Whole Ride

You were looking forward to a trail ride. Then: “What if he spins?” Suddenly excitement feels a lot like riding anxiety.

That feeling is real. But feeling afraid doesn't automatically mean something scary is about to happen. Sometimes it means your brain has told a very convincing story.

And sometimes that story comes from a past ride. After a fall, spook, or frightening moment, your brain tries to anticipate danger so you'll be prepared. It may be reacting to a memory, not what your horse is doing today.

Of course, real safety concerns deserve attention. If your horse is uncomfortable, the footing is poor, or you need more support, make a safer plan. Confidence isn't pretending everything is fine.

Trade “What If?” for “What's the Plan?”

You can't always control which thought trots into your head. You can practice how you respond.

NOTICE: “I'm imagining he'll spook.”

QUESTION: “Is something concerning happening now, or am I predicting what might happen?”

SHIFT: “What's the plan if he gets worried?” Maybe you start in the arena, ride with a trusted friend, or practice a calm halt before heading out.

Your thoughts aren't always facts. You don't have to believe every story your brain creates—or argue with it for an hour beside the tack room. One practical next step is enough.

Ready for Your Next Calm Step?

If fear of horseback riding is taking the joy out of time with your horse, let's talk. In a FREE Calm-Ride Strategy Session, we'll identify what's influencing your confidence and find a calm, achievable next step toward enjoying riding again.

You and your horse deserve that.



0 Comments

Leave a Comment


Hey there! I’m Elise Hittinger—Fear Slayer, Confidence Creator, and your go-to Courage Coach.

 
Once upon a time, I was that fearless kid riding deep into Angeles National Forest without a second thought. Then bam—life threw me a plot twist. A horse flipped on me, pinning me beneath it, and fear crept in like an uninvited guest who wouldn’t leave.

That moment tested everything. But here’s the wild part—I walked away with only bruises and a divine reminder that I wasn’t done yet. Fear may have stolen my joy for a while, but it did not get the final say.

Fast forward to a move to Kentucky, where the trails were calling my name. I had two choices: let fear keep the reins or take them back. Spoiler alert—I took them back. Now, I help other riders (and, honestly, anyone sick of fear running their life) do the same.

I make fear pack its little bags and GTFO. Whether it’s through hypnotherapy, NLP, or a little well-placed humor, I help people trade anxiety for confidence, doubt for courage, and overthinking for action.

So, if you’re ready to kick fear to the curb and rediscover the joy you deserve—I’m here for it. Let’s do this.

Contact