About the Author

Elise Hittinger - Courage Coach

Elise is a Courage Coach, Certified Hypnotherapist, and NLP Practitioner dedicated to helping anxious equestrians get out of their heads and back in the saddle with calm and confidence. Through her "Turn Riding Fear Around Podcast" and bestselling book, 'Rise from Fear to Courage,' she empowers riders to quiet the noise, reset their nervous systems, and reconnect with the joy of riding. She leads a thriving community of over 1,600 riders in her 'Overcoming Anxiety & Fear Horseback Riding' Facebook group. Learn more about Elise's transformative coaching through a Calm-Ride Strategy call.

How to Reduce Anxiety When Getting Back on Your Horse After an Accident

If you’ve had a riding accident, it’s completely understandable when swinging a leg back over feels like a lot. I’ve lived this. Here’s what I learned the hard way: for many of us, the hardest part isn’t the ride itself. It’s everything that happens before we even get on.

The good news? A little preparation goes a long way. When you take time to steady your mind, body, and confidence ahead of time, those first rides back can feel calmer and safer.

Why the First Few Rides After an Accident Feel So Hard

After a fall or scary moment, your brain starts treating riding like a threat. That’s not weakness. It’s your brain trying to keep you safe.

This is why just thinking about riding can bring up nerves, tight shoulders, or a flood of what-ifs. You might notice:

  • Nerves at the mounting block
  • Tension before you even swing up
  • Racing thoughts about what could go wrong
  • A strong urge to stay on the ground
  • Loss of that old confidence, even if you used to feel steady

Preparation helps show your brain, one step at a time, that you’re safe and in control.

How Preparation Reduces Riding Anxiety

Pushing through fear often makes the anxiety louder. But when you prepare with intention, you build a stronger foundation. Confidence is built, not magically found. It comes back through small, safe steps.

Close-up of a horse’s eye symbolizing focus, trust, and mental preparation before riding1. Prepare Your Mind Before You Ride

Your thoughts before riding shape how your body responds. If your mind is spinning worst-case scenarios, your body gets the message loud and clear.

Before those first few rides back, try this:

  • Picture a calm, successful mounting moment
  • Plan exactly what the ride will look like
  • Choose one simple goal—my first ride back was four steps… and that counted
  • Use easy breathing to quiet pre-ride nerves
  • Trade pressure for curiosity and a little grace

This kind of preparation gives your brain something steady to focus on.

 Woman stretching before horseback riding to improve balance, flexibility, and rider confidence2. Prepare Your Body to Feel Safer in the Saddle

Sometimes anxiety grows from tight hips, stiff shoulders, or feeling unsteady. After an accident, your body often braces without you even noticing. And remember: your horse feels what your body is saying.

Simple physical prep can help:

  • Gentle stretches for hips, back, and legs
  • Balance and mobility work off the horse
  • Practicing mounting and dismounting in a quiet way
  • Checking that your tack feels familiar and comfortable
  • Giving yourself extra time so nothing feels rushed

When your body feels supported, your brain believes the ride is manageable.

 Rider in a quiet arena creating a safe riding environment to rebuild confidence after a fall3. Prepare the Riding Situation Itself

One of the best ways to feel safer is to set the scene for success. You don’t need to prove anything. You just need a setup that supports you.

Helpful steps might include:

  • A quiet, familiar spot
  • A horse you trust
  • A calm person or instructor nearby
  • A short, achievable ride
  • Deciding ahead what counts as a win

For some riders, that win is simply standing at the mounting block without rushing. For others, it’s a short walk and finishing while still feeling steady. Both count.

If you want a little extra support before you ride, grab my Pre-Ride Checklist here. It’s a simple way to steady your mind, body, and plan for you and your horse before you swing a leg over.

4. Take the Pressure Off the First Few Rides

Many riders expect to feel confident right away. That pressure usually backfires. Instead, think of these rides as confidence rebuilding rides. Their job is to show your brain and body that riding can feel safe again.

Ask yourself:

  • What would feel like a calm next step?
  • What do I need in place before I ride?
  • How can I make this easier, not harder?

This approach works far better than trying to force yourself to be brave.

5. Celebrate Small Wins to Rebuild Equestrian Confidence

Confidence after a riding accident comes back one moment at a time. Every calm breath at the mounting block. Every short ride that ends on a good note. Those are the building blocks.

Notice things like:

  • Driving to the barn even when nerves showed up
  • Tacking up with steadier hands
  • Standing at the mounting block without panicking
  • Finishing a short ride while still feeling good
  • Choosing not to push past your limit

These aren’t small things when you’re coming back from fear. They’re real progress.

You Don’t Have to Do This the Hard Way

If you’re struggling with riding fear after a fall, you’re not alone. I’ve lived this. I found a faster way. And you can too.

With the right preparation and support, those first rides back can feel much more manageable than you expect. You can reduce pre-ride nerves, feel steadier at the mounting block, and start rebuilding trust in yourself step by step.

Need Help Creating a Calm Plan for Your First Rides Back?

If you want support getting back in the saddle after an accident, I offer a free Calm-Ride Strategy Call. We’ll look at where fear is showing up, understand what your brain is doing, and map out the next calm, doable step toward confident riding.

Book your free Calm-Ride Strategy Call today and take the first step toward enjoying riding again.


0 Comments

Leave a Comment


Hey there! I’m Elise Hittinger—Fear Slayer, Confidence Creator, and your go-to Courage Coach.

 
Once upon a time, I was that fearless kid riding deep into Angeles National Forest without a second thought. Then bam—life threw me a plot twist. A horse flipped on me, pinning me beneath it, and fear crept in like an uninvited guest who wouldn’t leave.

That moment tested everything. But here’s the wild part—I walked away with only bruises and a divine reminder that I wasn’t done yet. Fear may have stolen my joy for a while, but it did not get the final say.

Fast forward to a move to Kentucky, where the trails were calling my name. I had two choices: let fear keep the reins or take them back. Spoiler alert—I took them back. Now, I help other riders (and, honestly, anyone sick of fear running their life) do the same.

I make fear pack its little bags and GTFO. Whether it’s through hypnotherapy, NLP, or a little well-placed humor, I help people trade anxiety for confidence, doubt for courage, and overthinking for action.

So, if you’re ready to kick fear to the curb and rediscover the joy you deserve—I’m here for it. Let’s do this.

Contact